Florida Investment & Securities Lawyer
Call to Schedule a Consultation
561-417-8777

Judge Allows SEC Case Against Accused Oil & Gas Scam to Proceed

On December 31, 2014, a federal judge in Dallas denied a motion to dismiss a Securities and Exchange Commission complaint against a Texas man accused of defrauding investors out of nearly $10 million.

SEC v. Couch

The defendant, Charles Couch, owns Couch Oil & Gas, Inc. (COG) According to the SEC’s complaint, Couch and COG solicited investments in two sets of oil and gas programs. Couch allegedly raised $7 million for the first investment, known as the 59 Well Program, from 139 investors. The second investment, called the Radial Nine Program, raised about $2.8 million from 65 investors. The SEC said neither Program was properly registered as a securities offering.

Both programs offered “working interests” in existing oil and gas wells. But according to the SEC, Couch “never transferred any working interests to any investors,” and COG, which he wholly controlled, “retained all ownership interest in the Programs’ wells.” Nor did Couch tell investors that upwards of 30% of their money went to pay “sales commissions” to unregistered brokers, instead of going to pay the costs of actually drilling for oil and gas, as he had represented.

Furthermore, once the SEC initiated its investigation of Couch in 2011, he began to “wind down” the Radial Nine Program. However, his unregistered broker allegedly continued to sell investments in the program. The SEC said Radial Nine sold about 84% of its offering after the “wind down” decision, as investors were never informed of Couch’s ongoing regulatory issues.

Couch asked U.S. District Judge Sidney A. Fitzwater to dismiss the SEC’s complaint. Judge Fitzwater held “the SEC has pleaded facts sufficient to permit the court to draw the inference that the alleged misrepresentations made in the PPMs were made in connection with the purchase and sale of securities.” This is not a ruling on the merits, of course, only a finding the SEC’s complaint presents a plausible argument that, if proven, shows Couch committed securities fraud Judge Fitzwater also rejected dismissal on the grounds that Couch, by his account, only sold “interests in a joint venture” rather than securities governed by SEC rules. Citing U.S. Supreme Court precedent, Judge Fitzwater said the court must look to the “substance of the transaction” rather than what a party might call a particular investment. Here, despite the description of the two plans as “joint ventures” in the PPMs, Judge Fitzwater said the SEC had properly alleged they were, in fact, securities. Ultimately, this is an issue that will be resolved at trial.

Always Be Cautious

While this case remains pending in court, and the SEC still has to prove the charges against Couch, there are still important lessons for investors to learn. One is to never purchase securities from an unregistered broker. Another is to verify the exact nature of an investment before making any investment.. Oil and gas partnerships involve substantial risks and are only appropriate for sophisticated investors. Savvy investors must always be on the lookout for seemingly “can’t miss” investments.

If you have been the victim of an investment scam, contact Florida securities fraud attorney Gregory Tendrich, P.A., to discuss if you may be able to recover your investment losses.

Gregory Tendrich, PA
Gregory Tendrich, P.A. serves clients throughout Florida, including the cities of West Palm Beach, Palm Beach, Delray Beach, Boynton Beach, Boca Raton, Port St. Lucie, Lake Worth, Wellington, Riviera Beach, Palm Beach Gardens, Fort Pierce, Vero Beach, Hobe Sound, Jupiter Island, North Palm Beach, Lake Park, Lantana, Stuart, Palm City, Jensen Beach, Tequesta and Juno Beach and represents clients in Palm Beach County, Martin County, St. Lucie County, Indian River County and throughout Florida.

Our Location

3010 N. Military Trail, Suite 210
Boca Raton, FL 33431

Telephone: 561-417-8777
Fax: 561-417-8700

The information you obtain at this site is not, nor is it intended to be, legal advice. You should consult an attorney for individual advice regarding your own situation.

No content on this site may be reused in any fashion without written permission from www.YourStockLawyer.com

MileMark Media - Practice Growth Solutions

© 2015 - 2018 Gregory Tendrich, P.A. All rights reserved.
This law firm website is managed by MileMark Media.

Contact Form Tab